- Tubefilter
- Posts
- YouTube making money off misinformation? đ
YouTube making money off misinformation? đ
A $13.4 million investigation
TOGETHER WITH
Itâs Friday and if youâre not on the North Sea side of TikTok yet, just wait. At some point or another, this haunting sound comes for all FYPs.
MONETIZED MISINFORMATION
A new report says YouTube makes up to $13.4M/year by monetizing âclimate denialâ channels
Since 2021, climate change deniers have faced strict demonetization rules on YouTubeâbut according to a new report from the Center for Countering Digital Hate (CCDH), those misinformation policies might not enough.
Old rules, new loopholes: Three years ago, YouTube established a policy designed to demonetize content that contradicted âwell-established scientific consensus around the existence and causes of climate change.â That prohibition worked reasonably well for a whileâuntil climate deniers switched tactics.
According to the CCDH (which used an AI model to review 12,058 videos uploaded over six years across 96 channels), most climate deniers have ceased arguing that climate change doesnât exist.
Instead, 70% of the examined channels challenge the efficacy of proposed climate solutions, speculate that the effects of climate change are overblown, and/or criticize environmental science altogether.
Five years ago, those same tactics only dominated around 35% of channels.
The money trail: Despite YouTubeâs demonetization policy, the CCDHâs report found that YouTube makes up to $13.4 million a year from ads run on the 96 analyzed channels.
In other words: Climate-denying channels are falling through the cracks of YouTubeâs misinformation policy. Does the platform have enough incentives to change its rulebook?
After all, this isnât the first time researchers have raised concerns about YouTubeâs monetization of climate denial content; a similar report was published by Climate Action Against Disinformation (aka CAAD) last spring.
The official statement:
âDebate or discussions of climate change topics, including around public policy or research, is allowed. However, when content crosses the line to climate change denial, we stop showing ads on those videos.â
đ SPONSORED đ
Artlist is giving creators $100,000 to film a once-in-a-lifetime video from space
A few months back, Artlist asked creators to share their wildest dreams for the chance to win $100,000.
Now, after receiving thousands of inspiring submissions from creators worldwide, Artlist has selected their $100K Fund winner: Sent Into Space.
Sent Into Space is a visionary team with one core mission: capturing Earth's wonders from the edge of space. Their project aims to provide an immersive experience, allowing viewers to witness the beauty of the northern lights through a 360° production shot at the edge of space.
âAt the end of this project, we'll have an adventure documentary about going to extremesâŚto inspire explorers, cinematographers, stargazers, and the next generation of astronauts the world over.â
The creators behind Sent Into Space have always been fascinated by the universe beyond our atmosphere. Now, theyâre ready to share that fascination with viewers from all over the globe.
The teamâs genuine excitement shines through as they discuss their plansâa passion that demonstrates not only innovation, but also the power of creators to inspire the next generation.
Hit the link below to find out more about Sent Into Spaceâs groundbreaking projectâand donât forget to keep an eye out for Artlistâs next creator contest.
HEADLINES IN BRIEF đď¸
Beloved reptile expert Brian Barczyk has passed away of pancreatic cancer just one week after posting a farewell video addressed to his 5.3 million YouTube subscribers. (Tubefilter)
Former Fourthwall Head of Strategic Partnerships Zach Ferraro has signed on to lead Famous Birthdays Pro, a premium subscription that offers users access to more creator data. (Tubefilter)
Hachette Childrenâs will publish How to SHINE at Primary School: Build Classroom Confidence and Playground Positivity, an upcoming title by TikToker-slash-teacher Kit Brown. (Tubefilter)
Meta is reportedly restructuring its AI research teams as part of a push to develop artificial general intelligence (a form of AI designed to possess human or beyond-human intelligence). (The Verge)
COLUMNS ⢠STREAMERS ON THE RISE đ
This gaming streamer is ready to dive head-first into the vlogging world
In 2016, JoeWo kicked off his freshman year of college with âno idea what streaming was.â By graduation, he was on the precipice of becoming a full-time Twitch creator.
How it started: Growing up, JoeWo spent most of his time on the basketball court. College was a different story: without a competitive sport to occupy his time, the creator found himself looking for a new passion.
Gaming was the obvious choiceâespecially once JoeWo fell in love with Call of Dutyâbut it wasnât until the creatorâs junior year that streaming came into the picture. By that point, heâd gained enough familiarity with Twitch to know that a multiplatform approach was the way to go. So, he went all in: in addition to streaming on Twitch, JoeWo started posting on platforms like Twitter, YouTube, and TikTok.
Viewers began streaming in almost immediatelyâto the point that JoeWo was faced with a massive decision upon graduating: should he go to grad school, or start streaming full-time?
âEven though everybody was like, âYou have to go. Itâs grad school, obviously.â I was like, âOkay, thatâs going to sound crazy, but Iâm not going to go to grad school for you guys. Iâm going to try this dream that I have.ââ
How itâs going: Fast forward to 2024, and JoeWoâs leap of faith has paid off in a big way. His audience now includes 730K Twitch followers and 530K YouTube subscribers, and heâs built up a âgreat, great teamâ that helps keep his workload under control
Whatâs next: After years of chatting with fans and being an all-around âopen bookâ on Twitch, JoeWo is ready to fully embrace the vlogging world. Find out more about his plans for IRL content here.
STAY THE COURSE
Colin and Samir are launching a $1,797 âlive-cohort seriesâ with Kajabi
YouTube experts Colin Rosenblum and Samir Chaudry are gearing up to share exclusive business insights through a 30-day online course.
The collaboration: Rosenblum and Chaudryâs âlive-cohort seriesââcalled Creator Startupâis the result of a partnership with Kajabi, a creator economy company that has paid out more than $6 billion to creators through its suite of marketing, ecommerce, and audience development tools.
Over the last few months, Kajabi has focused on launching âdigital knowledge productsâ with notable creators. Thatâs where Rosenblum and Chaudry (and Creator Startup) come in.
The course: According to Kajabi, Creator Startup will cover value prop, process, and monetizationâthe kind of subjects rising creators often have to tackle independently through trial and error. That business-oriented focus is a key aspect of the course, which Chaudry says he and Rosenblum made âfor our younger selves.â
âLooking back, had we known what we know now, we would have had a much easier time turning our love of making videos into a business.â
The cost: The first Creator Startup cohort launches February 5, with enrollment priced at $1,797âbut that paid course isnât the only way creators can reap the rewards of Colin and Samirâs industry know-how. The duo is also offering free access to an Idea Generation Framework that they use for their own videos.
The context: Colin and Samir are the latest in a long line of veteran creators who have opened new revenue streams by sharing their hard-earned knowledge. Marques Brownlee, Jay Shetty, and Ninja have all released their own courses through MasterClass, providing an otherwise inaccessible level of guidance to the next generation of creators.
WATCH THIS ⢠SAMâS PICK đş
Anthony Hopkinsâ TikTok account is already the best part of 2024
Anthony Hopkins may have played Hannibal Lecter, but the 86-year-old actor himself is more comedian than cannibal.
Oscar-worthy performances: Since 2020, Hopkins has successfully charmed 3.4 million TikTok followers with goofy dance moves, poignant recitations, and well-wishes to other members of the sober community. Check out his wholesome account here.
âWe need a laugh in life. For good reason, I guess. Life is tough. The world is a savage place, but life has its beauty."
Was this email forwarded to you? Subscribe here.â
Today's newsletter is from: Emily Burton, Sam Gutelle, and Josh Cohen. Drew Baldwin helped edit, too. It's a team effort.